|
| If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|||||||
| Tags: cause, moves, relativitys, station, train |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
May 4th 07
posted to sci.physics.relativity
|
|||
|
|||
The station moves to the train? Relativity's Cause
The station does not move through space to get any closer to the
train. That is why there is no paradox. The cause of all SRelativistic effects is motion through space alone; nothing else. MITCH RAEMSCH -- LIGHT FELL -- 
|
| Ads |
|
#2
May 4th 07
posted to sci.physics.relativity
|
|||
|
|||
|
The station moves to the train? Relativity's Cause
"Nick" wrote in message
ps.com... The station does not move through space to get any closer to the train. Yes it does .. unless you claim there is an absolute 'aether' reference frame. In any case, a station on earth would be moving wrt to that frame (so it does move through space .. it just moves with the earth) That is why there is no paradox. There was no paradox to start with The cause of all SRelativistic effects is motion through space alone; nothing else. Really .. so you are in the Lorentz 'aether' camp?
|
|
#3
May 4th 07
posted to sci.physics.relativity
|
|||
|
|||
|
The station moves to the train? Relativity's Cause
On May 3, 9:10 pm, "Jeckyl" wrote:
"Nick" wrote in message ps.com... The station does not move through space to get any closer to the train. Yes it does .. unless you claim there is an absolute 'aether' reference frame. In any case, a station on earth would be moving wrt to that frame (so it does move through space .. it just moves with the earth) That is why there is no paradox. There was no paradox to start with The cause of all SRelativistic effects is motion through space alone; nothing else. Really .. so you are in the Lorentz 'aether' camp? No, This guy is a well know autistic troll, he is in the imbecile camp, you can ignore him.
|
|
#4
May 4th 07
posted to sci.physics.relativity
|
|||
|
|||
|
The station moves to the train? Relativity's Cause
On May 4, 6:10 am, "Jeckyl" wrote:
"Nick" wrote in message ps.com... The station does not move through space to get any closer to the train. Yes it does .. but tha train initiated tha motion between tha two, not tha station unless you claim there is an absolute 'aether' reference frame. In any case, a station on earth would be moving wrt to that frame (so it does move through space .. it just moves with the earth) That is why there is no paradox. There was no paradox to start with The cause of all SRelativistic effects is motion through space alone; nothing else. Really .. so you are in the Lorentz 'aether' camp?
|
|
#5
May 4th 07
posted to sci.physics.relativity
|
|||
|
|||
|
The station moves to the train? Relativity's Cause
On May 3, 9:03 pm, Nick wrote:
The station does not move through space to get any closer to the train. That is why there is no paradox. The cause of all SRelativistic effects is motion through space alone; nothing else. MITCH RAEMSCH -- LIGHT FELL -- 2005 called, it wants its' spewing idiot back.
|
|
#6
May 4th 07
posted to sci.physics.relativity
|
|||
|
|||
|
The station moves to the train? Relativity's Cause
On May 3, 9:18 pm, reproductor wrote:
On May 4, 6:10 am, "Jeckyl" wrote: "Nick" wrote in message ups.com... The station does not move through space to get any closer to the train. Yes it does .. but tha train initiated tha motion between tha two, not tha station unless you claim there is an absolute 'aether' reference frame. In any case, a station on earth would be moving wrt to that frame (so it does move through space .. it just moves with the earth) That is why there is no paradox. There was no paradox to start with The cause of all SRelativistic effects is motion through space alone; nothing else. Really .. so you are in the Lorentz 'aether' camp?- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - HOW DOES THE TRAIN MAKE THE STATION MOVE THROUGH SPACE? MITCH RAEMSCH -- LIGHT FELL --
|
|
#7
May 4th 07
posted to sci.physics.relativity
|
|||
|
|||
|
The station moves to the train? Relativity's Cause
On May 4, 6:24 am, Nick wrote:
On May 3, 9:18 pm, reproductor wrote: On May 4, 6:10 am, "Jeckyl" wrote: "Nick" wrote in message ups.com... The station does not move through space to get any closer to the train. Yes it does .. but tha train initiated tha motion between tha two, not tha station unless you claim there is an absolute 'aether' reference frame. In any case, a station on earth would be moving wrt to that frame (so it does move through space .. it just moves with the earth) That is why there is no paradox. There was no paradox to start with The cause of all SRelativistic effects is motion through space alone; nothing else. Really .. so you are in the Lorentz 'aether' camp?- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - HOW DOES THE TRAIN MAKE THE STATION MOVE THROUGH SPACE? right, it cant thay say that tha station start moving by itself, instantaneously with the train, which is an imposibility MITCH RAEMSCH -- LIGHT FELL --
|
|
#8
May 4th 07
posted to sci.physics.relativity
|
|||
|
|||
|
The station moves to the train? Relativity's Cause
"reproductor" wrote in message
ups.com... On May 4, 6:10 am, "Jeckyl" wrote: "Nick" wrote in message ps.com... The station does not move through space to get any closer to the train. Yes it does .. but tha train initiated tha motion between tha two, not tha station Irrelevant
|
|
#9
May 4th 07
posted to sci.physics.relativity
|
|||
|
|||
|
The station moves to the train? Relativity's Cause
"Nick" wrote in message
ups.com... HOW DOES THE TRAIN MAKE THE STATION MOVE THROUGH SPACE? What space .. you talk about it as though it is some fixed medium. The train moves through "space" as much as the train does .. indeed from a FoR of the sun, both the train and station are moving through space around the sun, as well as rotating with the earth. It just depends on your point of view.
|
|
#10
May 4th 07
posted to sci.physics.relativity
|
|||
|
|||
|
The station moves to the train? Relativity's Cause
"reproductor" wrote in message
ps.com... On May 4, 6:24 am, Nick wrote: HOW DOES THE TRAIN MAKE THE STATION MOVE THROUGH SPACE? right, it cant How does the station make the train move? Neither makes the other move, that are simple moving relative to each other thay say that tha station start moving by itself, instantaneously with the train, which is an imposibility You mean a reality.
|
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Yes, relativity's interesting .... | Joe Jakarta | Physics - General Discussion | 21 | October 18th 06 12:00 PM |
| Yes, relativity's interesting .... | Joe Jakarta | The Theory of Relativity | 21 | October 18th 06 12:00 PM |
| When the station comes to the train | Nick | Physics - General Discussion | 2 | July 6th 05 12:40 PM |
| When the station comes to the train | Nick | The Theory of Relativity | 2 | July 6th 05 12:40 PM |
| Model Maglev Train containg Hall Sensors on the train... Best Method? | David Garza | Electromagnetic Theory and Applications | 0 | February 25th 05 04:27 AM |
Linear Mode
