![]() |
| If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|||||||
| Tags: challenge, srians |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
|
Dear sirs!
Turn back the Fizeau experiment which be the classic experimental evidence for SR's velocity addition. Could it be that SR's velocity addition can also be disclaimed by the modification forms of the Fizeau experiment? Reconsider two modification forms of the Fizeau and Michelson-Morly experiments as follow: 1. According to the Fizeau experiment which were carried out in 1851, calling: - "n" is the refractive index of medium. - "u" is the speed of medium in comparison with the rest laboratory on earth. - "c/n" is the speed of light in the rest medium. - "c+" is the speed of light in the same direction of the motional medium. - "c-" is the speed of light in the contrary direction of the motional medium. According to Special Relativity's interpretation: The medium represent the K frame, the laboratery (or the earth) represent the K' frame. "u" is the relative speed of K and K' frame, "c/n" is the speed of light in the K frame (medium), "c+" and "c_" are the speed of light in K' frame (laboratory or earth). By the formula for velocity addition of Relativity, since uc, after some modifications, The light speed in the motion medium is determined by the formulas: c+ = (c/n)+(1-1/n^2)u, c_ = (c/n)-(1-1/n^2)u and this is agree with the experimental result. Now! I suppose that the above experiment be carried out in a travelling spacecraft at vo velocity in the universal space, the vectors vo of spacecraft and u of medium are same the direction. Some questions a What can represent the K, K' frames if we interpret the above result by the SR's velocity addition? Are the achievement values of result varied with the change of vo velocity of the spacecraft? suppossing that the result of experiment defind a value of c+ or c_ in the K' frame, then, what are the K, K' frames while the spacecraft being travelling in huge universal which no fulcrum? 2.Similarly, supposing that: the Michelson-Morly be carried out in condition having the water or glass medium in which a part of light wave is propagating. Since, the velocity of earth is the velocity of medium. To base on the experimental evidence of the Fizeau, a result which disclaim MMX's "null result" must be found. Then, how about our interpretation in that case? Sincere. ThanhMinh. |
| Ads |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| A Bogus Claim of SRians | kenseto | Physics - General Discussion | 52 | December 12th 04 05:50 AM |
| A challenge to non-SRians | Paul Miller | The Theory of Relativity | 307 | October 13th 04 09:57 PM |
| A challenge to non-SRians | greywolf42 | The Theory of Relativity | 1 | October 4th 04 09:09 PM |
| #2 Another Immortal Fumble of the SRians | GR_Learner@GR.grv | The Theory of Relativity | 23 | February 28th 04 03:58 PM |
| A Bogus Claim By The SRians | kenseto | The Theory of Relativity | 120 | December 10th 03 12:11 AM |