A challenge to non-SRians

**greywolf42** · #1 September 28th 04 posted to sci.physics.relativity

(Paul Miller) wrote in message
. com...

I don't really
see the point of doing this experiment for lots of different
orientations - shouldn't you just choose one orientation which you
think will show the biggest change in transit times?

Why do a half-assed job? Unlike the religious relativists, I don't
think
that I know everything. My expectation is that I'd find the effect to
be
aligned with the CMBR dipole / Miller's 1920's data.

Because of the practicalities, that's all. If you think multiple
orientations is doable, then let's do that.

Now. How about that win/lose criterion? Has Tom Roberts / your
anonymous
friend had time to consider this very basic and simple question?

I'll get back to you on this - I'm away until 13th Sept, but I'm sure
it won't take long to specify the details once I return.

Hello Paul? How was your trip?

- -
greywolf42
ubi dubium ibi libertas
{remove planet for e-mail}

**greywolf42** · #2 October 4th 04 posted to sci.physics.relativity

"greywolf42" wrote in message
...
(Paul Miller) wrote in message
. com...

I don't really
see the point of doing this experiment for lots of different
orientations - shouldn't you just choose one orientation which you
think will show the biggest change in transit times?

Why do a half-assed job? Unlike the religious relativists, I don't
think
that I know everything. My expectation is that I'd find the effect to
be
aligned with the CMBR dipole / Miller's 1920's data.

Because of the practicalities, that's all. If you think multiple
orientations is doable, then let's do that.

Now. How about that win/lose criterion? Has Tom Roberts / your
anonymous
friend had time to consider this very basic and simple question?

I'll get back to you on this - I'm away until 13th Sept, but I'm sure
it won't take long to specify the details once I return.

Hello Paul? How was your trip?

Paul, Hello? Do you have the details yet?

--
greywolf42
ubi dubium ibi libertas
{remove planet for e-mail}

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
A Bogus Claim of SRians	kenseto	Physics - General Discussion	52	December 12th 04 05:50 AM
A challenge to non-SRians	Paul Miller	The Theory of Relativity	307	October 13th 04 09:57 PM
#2 Another Immortal Fumble of the SRians	GR_Learner@GR.grv	The Theory of Relativity	23	February 28th 04 03:58 PM
Most of the Runts of the SRians Don't Undersatand SR.	kenseto	The Theory of Relativity	18	February 16th 04 01:34 AM
A Bogus Claim By The SRians	kenseto	The Theory of Relativity	120	December 10th 03 12:11 AM