A Physics forum. Physics Banter

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » Physics Banter forum » Physics Newsgroups » Physics - General Discussion
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

Tags: , , , , , ,

Difference between Chemistry and Physics and the Cold Fusion Controversy



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old April 4th 06 posted to sci.physics,sci.chem
cafeinst@msn.com
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 130
Default Difference between Chemistry and Physics and the Cold Fusion Controversy

Isn't it true that at one time scientists thought of chemistry and
physics as unrelated disciplines? When did this change? Can anyone
provide references about this?

Also, I've been reading about the Cold Fusion Pons/Fleischman
controversy. It seems that now many reputable scientists are reporting
that there is such a phenomenon. Some of these scientists say that Pons
and Fleischman were unfairly dismissed because the results of their
experiment did not conform to modern physics theories, not because they
did anything wrong in their experiment. How does the science community
at large view this controversy?

Craig

Ads
  #2  
Old April 5th 06 posted to sci.physics,sci.chem
john.spevacek@aspenresearch.com
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 17
Default Difference between Chemistry and Physics and the Cold Fusion Controversy


wrote:
Isn't it true that at one time scientists thought of chemistry and
physics as unrelated disciplines? When did this change? Can anyone
provide references about this?


You've probably seen those magnetic poetry kits, the ones where there
are a bunch of words with magnetic backings that you can stick to the
refrigerator and then shuffle them around to create a poem. With just
a little bit of practice, you can turn out at least a decent poem, and
maybe even something that is profound.

http://www.magneticpoetry.com/

Yet if you took those words and cut them up to form the individual
letters, it is far, far more difficult to make up a such a poem or some
profound thoughts. This is surprising as the available information is
the same in both cases. Clearly, information does depend on the way in
which it is presented.

Whole words: chemistry
Individual letters: physics

Size does matter.

John
Aspen Research, - www.aspenresearch.com
"Turning Questions into Answers"

Opinions expressed herein are my own and may not represent those of my
employer.

  #3  
Old April 9th 06 posted to sci.physics,sci.chem
Jeff…Relf
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 4,207
Default Difference between Chemistry and Physics and the Cold Fusion Controversy

Hi Cafeinst, You asked about cold fusion,

From Wikipedia.ORG/wiki/Cold_fusion#Other_kinds_of_fusion

Pyroelectric fusion was reported in April 2005 by a team at UCLA.

The scientists used a pyroelectric crystal heated from −34 to 7°C
( −30 to 45°F ), combined with a tungsten needle to produce
an electric field of about 25 gigavolts per meter
to ionize and accelerate deuterium nuclei into an erbium deuteride target.

Though the energy of the deuterium ions generated by the crystal
has not been directly measured, the authors used 100 keV
( a temperature of about 109 K ) as an estimate in their modeling.

At these energy levels, two deuterium nuclei can fuse together
to produce a helium-3 nucleus, a 2.45 MeV neutron and bremsstrahlung.

Although it makes a useful neutron generator,
the apparatus is not intended for power generation since
it requires far more energy than it produces.


  #4  
Old April 9th 06 posted to sci.physics,sci.chem
Eric Gisse
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 17,511
Default Difference between Chemistry and Physics and the Cold Fusion Controversy


Jeff...Relf wrote:

[snip usual Relf droppings]

STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS
STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO SCI.PHYSICS STOP POSTING TO
SCI.PHYSICS

 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Physics Nobel Laureate speaks out on cold fusion and the paranormal Jack Sarfatti Physics - General Discussion 0 February 28th 05 03:21 PM
Cold Fusion-- the rest of physics is better? Gregory L. Hansen Physics - General Discussion 10 January 18th 05 01:01 AM
Cold Fusion Gets Chilly Encore - Physics Today JohnnyCJohnny Fusion Discussions 0 December 31st 04 02:01 PM
Cold fusion is the biggest lie of physics !!!!! Bruno Beam Fusion Discussions 3 December 15th 04 07:01 PM
Greenview Helps Clarify the Controversy Over Cold Fusion JohnnyCJohnny Fusion Discussions 12 December 9th 04 05:15 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:54 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 2.4.0
Copyright ©2004-2008 Physics Banter, part of the NewsgroupBanter project.
The comments are property of their posters.
Advertising - Car Insurance - Car Finance - Loans - Deals On Products