![]() |
| If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|||||||
| Tags: causes, dilation, time |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
|
First, I am not a physicist. I do desktop publishing as a profession, but am
an avid sci-fi reader. Two related questions. What causes time to slow down as a ship approaches the speed of light? Is there any possibility that we could create the effect on a stationary object? Imagine a room in which time was slowed down to say 1% normal. One year might in it might equal 100 years. |
| Ads |
|
#2
|
|||
|
|||
|
hunkahunkaburninluv wrote:
First, I am not a physicist. I do desktop publishing as a profession, but am an avid sci-fi reader. Two related questions. What causes time to slow down as a ship approaches the speed of light? Is there any possibility that we could create the effect on a stationary object? Imagine a room in which time was slowed down to say 1% normal. One year might in it might equal 100 years. Nothing changes within a reference frame. The reference frames relative to each other have a different mix of space and time as a hyperbolic rotation through 4-space. You cannot have disparate time rates within a reference frame. It violates thermodynamics. -- Uncle Al http://www.mazepath.com/uncleal/ (Toxic URL! Unsafe for children and most mammals) http://www.mazepath.com/uncleal/qz.pdf |
|
#3
|
|||
|
|||
|
hunkahunkaburninluv wrote:
First, I am not a physicist. I do desktop publishing as a profession, but am an avid sci-fi reader. Two related questions. What causes time to slow down as a ship approaches the speed of light? Is there any possibility that we could create the effect on a stationary object? Imagine a room in which time was slowed down to say 1% normal. One year might in it might equal 100 years. See: http://scienceworld.wolfram.com/phys...elativity.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physic....html#intro_sr |
|
#4
|
|||
|
|||
|
"hunkahunkaburninluv" wrote in message ... First, I am not a physicist. I do desktop publishing as a profession, but am an avid sci-fi reader. Two related questions. What causes time to slow down as a ship approaches the speed of light? Is there any possibility that we could create the effect on a stationary object? Imagine a room in which time was slowed down to say 1% normal. One year might in it might equal 100 years. Sure you can do that by modification of the space-time metric, that is, by increasing the curvature of space, for some limited region of space. For, example, see to it that the gravitational field is increased in that special room of yours. Actually, a field isn't required. All you need is a huge amount of gradient-free, negative gravitational potential. You can do that by constructing a massive spherical shell about yourself. Then, through peepholes in the shell, you can watch time fly by on the shell's outer surface, all in weightless comfort. However, for a large factor in time-rates between you and those on the surface, the people on the surface would be living (?) in a huge gravitational field. So, lets put them out in space, almost an infinite distance away. Then the ratio in time rates between you and them is given by delta_t (you) / delta_t (them) = sqrt[ 1 - 2 M / R c^2 ] where M and R are the mass and radius of the shell, and G is the universal gravitational constant. Note that your time approaches zero (their time approaches infinity) as the mass of the shell, M, approaches that of a black- hole of radius, R, but everyone lives in free-fall comfort. See: "Gravity: An Introduction to ... " by J.B. Hartle ISBN 0-8053-8662-9 [Old Man] |
|
#5
|
|||
|
|||
|
"hunkahunkaburninluv" wrote in message ...
First, I am not a physicist. I do desktop publishing as a profession, but am an avid sci-fi reader. Two related questions. What causes time to slow down as a ship approaches the speed of light? According to SR in the Twin Paradox experiment, nature grants to the astronaut twin a slower time rate because the spaceship travels faster than the earth in leaving it and then in returning to it. Accepting as true that the astronaut twin ages less than his earth-bound twin, and since the only essential difference during the experiment between the twins was their state of motion in space, I contend that time is a property of matter and that time passes for discrete objects or systems inversely proportional to their states of motion. So nature grants objects/systems moving faster than other objects/systems longer time rates, and thus longer lives (relatively speaking, of course). Why nature does such a thing can best be explained with the claim that time is a property of discrete matter/systems. Is there any possibility that we could create the effect on a stationary object? Imagine a room in which time was slowed down to say 1% normal. One year might in it might equal 100 years. It is possible even though there are no really stationary objects. The universe is expanding and everything in it is moving so the only things we can say are stationary are things moving at constant velocity relatively to each other, but then they can only be considered stationary in relation to each other. E.g., you, your desk, and your pc are stationary with respect to each other. Anything and everything else not moving at constant velocity wrt to you cannot be said by you to be stationary. So, imagine a kid-sized model railroad track set up within your room so that a kid can ride the train while you sit next to the track watching the train go by. Both of you have at hand 25th century clocks which can accurately, I say, accurately, measure the time it takes a photon from a light bulb in the ceiling of the train car to reach the floor. The kid will measure the time as e.g., x, but your measurement will be longer, i.e., x + the additional time involved in which the light travels a curved path to the floor. The distance as viewed by the kid can be delineated as a straight vertical line stretching from the ceiling to the floor. For you, the light follows a curved path because the train is moving along as the photon falls, while you remain stationary wrt the train. It takes the light a little bit longer to reach the floor from your perspective, but the difference is hardly noticible because the speed of the train is so slow. To put into effect a 100 years span requires that the train travel much faster, even faster than the spaceship twin! |
|
#6
|
|||
|
|||
|
hunkahunkaburninluv wrote:
First, I am not a physicist. I do desktop publishing as a profession, but am an avid sci-fi reader. Two related questions. What causes time to slow down as a ship approaches the speed of light? The geometry of spacetime. You could equally well ask: "What causes a rod to look shorter if I look at an angle to it?" Is there any possibility that we could create the effect on a stationary object? First: stationary with respect to what? Presumably to observer... Second: time dilation can also be caused by strong gravitational fields. Does that help? Imagine a room in which time was slowed down to say 1% normal. One year might in it might equal 100 years. Well, sounds like a way to "travel" into the future. ;-) Bye, Bjoern |
|
#7
|
|||
|
|||
|
"TomGee" wrote in message om... "hunkahunkaburninluv" wrote in message ... First, I am not a physicist. I do desktop publishing as a profession, but am an avid sci-fi reader. Two related questions. What causes time to slow down as a ship approaches the speed of light? According to SR in the Twin Paradox experiment, nature grants to the astronaut twin a slower time rate because the spaceship travels faster than the earth in leaving it and then in returning to it. Not at all. Nature doesn't do anything. Time dilation is "caused" by the way we measure things. See also Bjoern's reply. Dirk Vdm |
|
#8
|
|||
|
|||
|
In article ,
"Dirk Van de moortel" wrote: "TomGee" wrote in message om... "hunkahunkaburninluv" wrote in message ... First, I am not a physicist. I do desktop publishing as a profession, but am an avid sci-fi reader. Two related questions. What causes time to slow down as a ship approaches the speed of light? According to SR in the Twin Paradox experiment, nature grants to the astronaut twin a slower time rate because the spaceship travels faster than the earth in leaving it and then in returning to it. Not at all. Nature doesn't do anything. Time dilation is "caused" by the way we measure things. For example, pain causes time dilation. So does boredom. See also Bjoern's reply. /BAH Subtract a hundred and four for e-mail. |
|
#9
|
|||
|
|||
|
"hunkahunkaburninluv" wrote in message ... First, I am not a physicist. I do desktop publishing as a profession, but am an avid sci-fi reader. Two related questions. What causes time to slow down as a ship approaches the speed of light? Is there any possibility that we could create the effect on a stationary object? Imagine a room in which time was slowed down to say 1% normal. One year might in it might equal 100 years. Time dilation is an effect of the fact that the speed of light is the same in all uniformly moving (with respect to each other) frames of reference. John. |
|
#10
|
|||
|
|||
|
Uncle Al wrote:
hunkahunkaburninluv wrote: First, I am not a physicist. I do desktop publishing as a profession, but am an avid sci-fi reader. Two related questions. What causes time to slow down as a ship approaches the speed of light? Is there any possibility that we could create the effect on a stationary object? Imagine a room in which time was slowed down to say 1% normal. One year might in it might equal 100 years. Nothing changes within a reference frame. The reference frames relative to each other have a different mix of space and time as a hyperbolic rotation through 4-space. You cannot have disparate time rates within a reference frame. It violates thermodynamics. -- Uncle Al http://www.mazepath.com/uncleal/ (Toxic URL! Unsafe for children and most mammals) http://www.mazepath.com/uncleal/qz.pdf You have variable time rates in a gravitational field... Time runs faster at your head than at your feet. WHy would that violate thermodynamics? Marcel, |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| What happens in time dilation, and other things | Johnathan Doe | Physics - General Discussion | 7 | July 5th 04 03:54 PM |
| Time Dilation Experiments | Sam Wormley | Physics - General Discussion | 1 | June 6th 04 08:08 PM |
| An idea for a way to visualize time dilation | Bunburry | Physics - General Discussion | 1 | February 28th 04 05:19 PM |
| Time dilation - No Need to Do the Math | Stephen Bint | Physics - General Discussion | 147 | November 7th 03 09:03 AM |
| MMX and Time Dilation | Peter Riedt | Physics - General Discussion | 58 | October 22nd 03 10:52 AM |