"Dirk Van de moortel" wrote
in message ...

"Harold Ensle" wrote in message
...

I took another look at these and I am astonished at your inability
to understand my statements.

Antirelativity and the Stupidity Machine:
http://users.pandora.be/vdmoortel/di...s/Reading.html

This one was merely a case of reading my post OUT OF CONTEXT to usual
discussion involving ether theories. You purposely played stupid (well
maybe you weren't playing) in order to claim some kind of self contradiction
on my part. Of course, it was all clarified later in the thread, but you
ignored
it. Why? Because these are not real fumbles. They are your response to
your own transparent inferiority complex. You really should seek some help.

http://users.pandora.be/vdmoortel/di...Instantly.html

This one was actually quite good, if there was someone who could
understand it. What is truely amazing is that on several occasions you
actually grabbed the key arguments that should have caused the case
to be understood. It was as if your subconscious new this and thus
responded with kneejerking emotion to cover-up the fact that *this*
was the argument.

This comment was in response to the Doppler analysis of the twin
paradox. In this scenario, the argument is that the travelling twin
instantly sees the Doppler shift whereas the stay-at- home does
not until the light gets to him. Of course, I brought up the *obvious
point* that if the travelling twin is at rest (which is perfectly allowable
in SR) then he would see the opposite occurance.

For some reason that this person sees it as a fumble.....apparently because
he doesn't understand the argument (He has never given any explanation
for any of these choices BTW).

http://users.pandora.be/vdmoortel/di...nnotApply.html

Here was another critical argument that just eluded Dirk. I simply wrote
that
a person at rest could not apply the Lorentz transformation to himself.
This is obviously true, so how could it be a fumble?

http://users.pandora.be/vdmoortel/di...easonable.html

This was just an off-the-cuff personal opinion, which was somewhat
prejudicial, but ironically Dirk certainly fits the comment himself,
as he has so masterfully demonstrated here.

H.Ellis Ensle