Thread
:
The case for and against genius
View Single Post
#
31
October 16th 04 posted to sci.physics
Fabrizio J. Bonsignore
external usenet poster
Posts: 165
The case for and against genius
wrote in message ...
[spit]
In article ,
(Fabrizio J. Bonsignore) wrote:
"Morituri-Max" wrote in message
...
Fabrizio J. Bonsignore wrote:
So you haven't understand yet. The fact that there are many "workers"
in a field doesn't MEAN that there is not a single source.
Nor does it mean that there is a single source.. You are basing a
premise on a
very weak foundation.
In fact, all of them had a very genial idea, am I right?
genial?
I think he intends the word to be an adverb form of genius and
using it as an adjective.
And they developed it to create a whole field; each one contribuing
an aspect. And the field in a way is complete. But also, is there a
hierarchy of ideas in their ideas?
..no, merely a common desire to learn and advance our understanding of
how the
universe works.
That is, do you have a root idea from which stems another, and
until you have that one, comes the other, etc?
No. There are plenty of examples of scientists on completely different
continents coming up with the same breakthrough in science at about the
same
time.. then it is a matter of who publishes first.. after which they
sometimes
collaborate on refining their ideas.
Depends on the idea. Obvious ideas will be anticipated. Genial ones
belong to a single individual and may never be discovered again. You
have to refine your conception of knowledge. Mine is a tree.
We have been telling you that you are wrong considering it to
be a tree. If you superimpose a web connecting all nodes of
your tree, you will take a first step of understanding.
/BAH
Subtract a hundred and four for e-mail.
You mean a semantic net? But reason proceeds step by step, like in
sylogisms, so there is a tree. Think of course 101, where you learn
superficially, and then course 303 where you learn *some* of the same
things but in deepness. Say, introduction to economics and then
macroeconomics, and then central bank policies and then open market
operations, etc. There is an implied tree, though admittedly there is
an enmeshed web. Like in a very net with thinh threads and then some
rather rigid threads that form an inner structure with the form of a
tree...
Fabrizio J. Bonsignore
View Public Profile
View message headers
Find all posts by Fabrizio J. Bonsignore
Find all threads started by Fabrizio J. Bonsignore
Ads
Home Loan
-
Debt Consolidation
-
Refinance
-
Debt Consolidation
-
BeSEO Recreation Directory