El Enrrabadore-mor wrote:
"Tom Roberts" escreveu na mensagem
...
Look at the subject of this thread. "simplifying" to circular motion is
what is being discussed.

Such simplification makes your solution ridiculous, that's all.
It's not "ridiculous", it is what this thread is about. I gave a general
equation (in response to an inquiry), and then applied it to the subject
of this thread. shrug

If you find the thread subject (the original inquiry) ridiculous,

YOU are the one who claimed it was "ridiculous", not I. If this is the
level of your accuracy of reading and remembering what YOU wrote, then
discussing anything with you is hopeless....


I must say it is not, since it is just a limit case of a very
real and possible situation.

Yes. THAT'S WHAT I SAID!


[... further nonsense unrelated to the subject]


Tom Roberts