This message is brought to you by Androcles
http://www.androcles01.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/
"El Enrrabadore-mor" wrote in message
...
|
| "Tom Roberts" escreveu na mensagem
| t...
| El Enrrabadore-mor wrote:
| It is said that a speeding clock shows less elapsed time than
| the stay-at-home clock, because (if already speeding) it is
| running at a slower rate. Or else, because it had run at a
| slower rate when it was speeding, assuming now it is
| stopped near the stay-at-home clock.
|
| While that may be "said", it is wrong in SR. In SR, the motion of a
clock
| does not affect its rate. But when one compares identical clocks that
have
| traveled different paths, their elapsed proper times can differ, due to
| their different trajectories, not due to any change in their tick rates.
|
| It looks like you have a new theory here.
| Instead of velocity being the cause of time dilatation, now
| it is the trajectory the cause of time dilatation.
|
| Below, you say that circular motion and linear motion
| causes exactly the same muons lifetime. Since circular
| and linear motions are the extreme limits of possible
| trajectories, it looks like that you have contradicted
| yourself.
|
|
| [... circular motion]
|
| Bailey et al put muons into a storage ring and measured their lifetime
for
| their circular path. Within experimental resolutions, they have the same
| lifetime as muons traveling in a straight line, so their circular path
did
| NOT affect the internal "clock" that controls their decay. They were
| subject to an acceleration of about 10^18 g (1 g = 9.8 m/s^2), which is
| FAR greater than claimed in your example. Note this experiment is a
direct
| implementation of the circular twin scenario, when combined with
| measurements of muon decay at rest.
|
| This one is extraordinary.
| You claim that Bailey et al experiment showed that muons
| lifetime doesn't depend on the acceleration.
| It is said that one single experiment that falsifies GRT is
| reason enough to discard a theory.
| So there you are. You've presented an experiment that
| simply falsifies GRT.
| Why don't you discard GRT based on evidence like that?
|
|
You want the Pope to give up virgin births?