View Single Post
  #9  
Old March 4th 08 posted to sci.physics.relativity
PD
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 20,055
Default How does one use a Minkowski diagram?

On Mar 4, 8:35*am, "
wrote:
On Mar 4, 4:23*pm, PD wrote:





On Mar 4, 6:08*am, "
wrote:


I'm not sure I know exactly how to use the Minkowski diagram. For
example, let's say you have a stationary observer and a moving
observer, and an event somewhere, for which the coordinates are x and
t in the stationary frame and x' and t' in the moving frame. How do
you get t', for example, from the Minkowski diagram?


Ram.


No, you can't. The temptation is to use a Minkowski diagram like a 2D
Euclidean geometry, which would allow you to do all sorts of Euclidean
geometrical constructions (with a compass and a straight edge) and
trigonometric relations. But the relationship between x and t in a
Minkowski diagram is NOT Euclidean, and you will quickly run into
problems if you try to apply Euclidean rules to it.


PD


Are you saying that I cannot get x' and t' from the Minkowski diagram?
Because the page at Wikipedia says that this is its purpose. And if I
can get x' and t' from it, how do I do it? I tried the method that
they say in Wikipedia, but it didn't come out like the Lorentz
transformation. What am I missing?


I suggest you buy a book. Spacetime Physics, by Taylor and Wheeler.
Very affordable when bought used. Do not attempt to learn physics from
the internet or from Usenet.


Ram.- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -


Ads
 

0 Credit Cards - Credit Card - Home Loan - Personal Loans - Just Holden Commodores