On Feb 10, 4:11*pm, spoonbender wrote:
On Feb 10, 8:29 pm, wrote:

No body said "nothing".
Try reading good references.
No body said "nothing", they just don't know what exactly happen
before the bang.
But that doesn't matter to know the event after it.
So its not much of a concern right now.

are you kidding us?

your "before" involves time

what time are talkin about before
bigbang or whatever?

xxein: Do you have an end with no beginning? If you have no end,
there was no beginning.

Time is merely a process rate for a changing existence. How do you
wish time would NOT be if there is changing existense?