"Chris" wrote in message
. uk...
:I don't think he was wrong, just misunderstood and I don't understand it
: either.
:
: The lorenz transform is symmentrical

Ok, that is why you don't understand it. What you have NOT
done is examined how the "Lorentz Transformations" (which I call
the cuckoo malformations) came into non-existence.
The mathematics is in section 3 of
"On The Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies" by Albert Crazy Einstein,
and I've explained it he
http://www.androcles01.pwp.blueyonde...mart/Smart.htm